Spectacular What To Say In A Referee Report
Determine If It Is Appropriate to Write a Reply.
What to say in a referee report. At some point during your job search you will be asked to provide a list of refereesYou might do this as you fill out a job application or it might happen later during the interview phase. You then give their contact details when asked. 3 April 2008 pp.
That might seem too obvious to mention but many reports fail to do this. Referees reports are often demoralizing to authors. BEven if your speed is not useful to the Editor because maybe there is a second referee so what will matter for the publication process is the lowest speed not the fastest still if a above is positively concluded then your speed willbe appreciated and remembered.
Regardless of its quality most papers have something good about them and authors might be just a tad happier if their hard work was acknowledged more often. Younger I will say a few more things like play to my whistle dont stop just because a ball hits someones hand Something like that. All information especially those required ones should be indicated or provided in the referee report.
For example many reports will list a series of criticisms andor virtues of the paper but make no mention of the weight or importance of these various considerations. Try to avoid biases. Let the editors know if you need any additional information from the authors to help you write a balanced and well-substantiated report.
Anything over U14 if it is a DA or premiere team I am just headstails whats the call and away we go. I have commented below on each of the points raised by the referees. How do you respond to a referee report.
City of Mason COVID-19. Start with the conclusion. Finally regardless of my recommendation I try to say something nice about the paper both in the editor letter and in the report.